Where would you like to start your search?

"I took my teenager to dinner here. She was thrilled to read about the history & ghost stories. Our waiter provided excellent service and thrilled my daughter with stories of his own experiences. The plates were huge and the food was delicious. "

"The food and staff at my daughters wedding reception was top shelf we all had a great time could not ask for any thing more even the ghosts had a good time."

"We recently dined there twice in a week. The first time was to try their lobster bisque which we all agreed is probably the best on the Cape. Many large pieces of lobster in a divine bisque. The second time we were there for a full dinner, and were all delighted with the three course price fix for $25. Everyone's entire dinner was fabulous. This is a new favorite place. Also you can't beat the Sunday brunch."

"we have only been to the inn on sundays for the breakfast buffet, which is always excellent. Each time we go there is something different. We live here yr round with a 1 yr old and a 3 yr old who are always welcomed which is a very nice feeling, being able to go to a family friendly place without sacraficing the ambiance and upscale feeling. we look forward to trying the restaraunt other than the brunch."

"The wine is served in very large glasses, not skimpy little glasses. The food has always been excellent. My favorite is the beef tips with gorganzola. YUM. We like the pizzas, too. The burgers are delicious, the fish is delicious. I have seen many plates of short ribs go by that look delicious, too! The waitstaff are the best waitstaff of any place I have ever eaten. We are locals who like to eat at the better places around....we do not know the owners or employees so we can't say we are writing a biased review. We just like good food and nice people."

"Take advantage of cape cod restauraunt week and try their best of the best at an affordable price. The scallps in bacon were perfectly cooked and seafood cocktail is fantastic. The rack of lamb is the best I've had on the cape and veal is always done just right no matter the dish. Try the lobster risotto topped with tempura lobster if you find it on the menu! "

"So smooth and an amazing amount of LOBSTER. We had a big bowl of bisque, delicious ciabatta and a yummy Viognier!! SO GOOD!!"

"I gotta say this last reviewer must have a personal grudge against the owner or management. The Old Yarmouth Inn is one of our favorites and although I have had a few good meals for the most part they have always been great. I had a glass of exceptional Pinot noir and I asked, Dani how many ounces in a glass of wine and I was told 6 ounces. So not be swayed by the last grumpy person. We have been going for more than 3 years and look forward to many more meals to come"

"Looks like the owners have posted a bunch of reviews here!! Always happens with this site. My dinner was a fish francese. The sole was sort of pan fried and not too bad. The strange lemon sauce was fairly gooey and was either a mix or canned. Served on top of mushy spaghetti. All in all a nice old inn to take grandma to on her birthday but not for the food......
"

"Great place and nice folks but I ordered an expensive steak and it had a muscle right down the middle. Had to eat on each side of the meat. Probably should have sent it back. "

"Brunch is a wonderful and relaxing experience. We make a point to visit every time we are on Cape and are never disappointed. The quality of the food is excellent and the staff is very attentive!"

"Everytime we go here the food is always delicious! I tried a new pasta dish with crab and angel hair it was served hot and the flavors were perfect. My wife had the Baked Stuffed Lobster...nothing like it anywhere. "

"There is no better than this place! Romantic, excellent food , ambiance is perfect and waitstaff is second to none! Try the lobster ravioli...to die for....Filet Steaks melt in your mouth...you will not be disappointed!"

"We visit the cape 6 weeks each summer and always start our Restaurant dining at the Old Yarmouth Inn. The food, drink, and service is fantastic. We've never had a bad experience. "

"Baked Stuffed Shrimp....smoked salmon...prime rib....the best eggs benedict. NOT your average brunch offerings...extraordinary. Every time!"

"In the past, we've enjoyed their brunches. But yesterday we went for Mother's Day brunch and were sorely disappointed. First of all, the price was steep-$34.95 pp. Which I'd gladly pay if the food was as delicious and varied as they claimed it would be when we called for reservations. The food was mediocre, and just standard brunch fare. The best dishes were the macaroni & cheese and hot veggies. Desserts were good, but none "to die for." It was very crowded. And each time we got up from our table, we had to avoid smashing into the wait staff, who were running around crazily. Often there were lines at the main food station, but the omelet/bacon/sausage station, which was set up in the lounge, went virtually untouched. I bet some diners didn't even know it was there. Next year we'll probably go to the Dan'l Webster."

"My wife and I eat here each time we visit the cape. The Clams Casino are out of this world. Overall great dining experience."